{"data":{"deterministic":false,"headline":"No verdict: two independent formalizations of the text lead to different answers.","nextStep":"Rewrite the ambiguous clause so it has one reading (see translation.equivalence.distinguishing for a case where the readings differ), or submit the formal IR.","status":"UNKNOWN","verdict":"TRANSLATION_DISAGREEMENT","mode":"possible","confidence":"low","result":{},"translation":{"llmCalls":3,"vocabulary":[{"name":"payout_above_10000","type":"bool","min":"","max":""},{"name":"approved_by_manager","type":"bool","min":"","max":""},{"name":"approved_by_director","type":"bool","min":"","max":""},{"name":"is_manager","type":"bool","min":"","max":""},{"name":"is_director","type":"bool","min":"","max":""}],"candidates":[{"tier":"standard","usable":true,"provider":"openrouter","model":"anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5","ir":{"variables":[{"name":"payout_above_10000","type":"bool"},{"name":"approved_by_manager","type":"bool"},{"name":"approved_by_director","type":"bool"},{"name":"is_manager","type":"bool"},{"name":"is_director","type":"bool"}],"constraints":[{"id":"C2","expr":{"op":"implies","args":[{"op":"var","name":"payout_above_10000"},{"op":"var","name":"approved_by_director"}]},"source":"Payouts above $10,000 require approval by a director."},{"id":"C3","expr":{"op":"implies","args":[{"op":"var","name":"is_manager"},{"op":"not","args":[{"op":"var","name":"is_director"}]}]},"source":"A manager is never a director."}],"query":{"mode":"possible","formula":{"op":"and","args":[{"op":"var","name":"payout_above_10000"},{"op":"var","name":"approved_by_manager"}]},"source":"Can a payout above $10,000 be approved by a manager?"}},"verified":[{"clauseId":"C2","quote":"Payouts above $10,000 require approval by a director.","formula":"(implies payout_above_10000 approved_by_director)"},{"clauseId":"C3","quote":"A manager is never a director.","formula":"(implies is_manager (not is_director))"}],"dropped":[],"status":"SAT","verdict":"POSSIBLE","result":{"model":[{"name":"payout_above_10000","type":"bool","value":true},{"name":"approved_by_manager","type":"bool","value":true},{"name":"approved_by_director","type":"bool","value":true},{"name":"is_manager","type":"bool","value":false},{"name":"is_director","type":"bool","value":false}]}},{"tier":"deep","usable":true,"provider":"openrouter","model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5","ir":{"variables":[{"name":"payout_above_10000","type":"bool"},{"name":"approved_by_manager","type":"bool"},{"name":"approved_by_director","type":"bool"},{"name":"is_manager","type":"bool"},{"name":"is_director","type":"bool"}],"constraints":[{"id":"C1","expr":{"op":"implies","args":[{"op":"var","name":"approved_by_manager"},{"op":"var","name":"is_manager"}]},"source":"Any payout request may be approved by a manager."},{"id":"C2","expr":{"op":"implies","args":[{"op":"var","name":"payout_above_10000"},{"op":"var","name":"approved_by_director"}]},"source":"Payouts above $10,000 require approval by a director."},{"id":"C2","expr":{"op":"implies","args":[{"op":"var","name":"approved_by_director"},{"op":"var","name":"is_director"}]},"source":"approval by a director"},{"id":"C3","expr":{"op":"not","args":[{"op":"and","args":[{"op":"var","name":"is_manager"},{"op":"var","name":"is_director"}]}]},"source":"A manager is never a director."}],"query":{"mode":"possible","formula":{"op":"and","args":[{"op":"var","name":"payout_above_10000"},{"op":"var","name":"approved_by_manager"}]},"source":"Can a payout above $10,000 be approved by a manager?"}},"verified":[{"clauseId":"C1","quote":"Any payout request may be approved by a manager.","formula":"(implies approved_by_manager is_manager)"},{"clauseId":"C2","quote":"Payouts above $10,000 require approval by a director.","formula":"(implies payout_above_10000 approved_by_director)"},{"clauseId":"C2","quote":"approval by a director","formula":"(implies approved_by_director is_director)"},{"clauseId":"C3","quote":"A manager is never a director.","formula":"(not (and is_manager is_director))"}],"dropped":[],"status":"UNSAT","verdict":"IMPOSSIBLE","result":{"core":{"clauses":["C1","C2","C3"],"minimal":true},"vacuous":false,"statement":"(and payout_above_10000 approved_by_manager) is impossible under clauses C1, C2, C3."}}],"equivalence":{"question":"DIFFERENT","rules":"DIFFERENT","distinguishing":{"scope":"question","assignment":[{"name":"payout_above_10000","type":"bool","value":true},{"name":"approved_by_manager","type":"bool","value":true},{"name":"approved_by_director","type":"bool","value":true},{"name":"is_manager","type":"bool","value":false},{"name":"is_director","type":"bool","value":true}],"first":true,"second":false}},"note":"The two translations lead to different verdicts; the distinguishing assignment is in translation.equivalence and neither verdict is selected."},"audit":{"solver":"cdcl-lra-ts","version":"1.0.0","algorithm":"Tseitin CNF; CDCL (two watched literals, 1-UIP learning, EVSIDS, Luby restarts, LBD/activity clause deletion); DPLL(T) with general simplex over exact BigInt rationals (Dutertre & de Moura 2006) with bound propagation; branch-and-bound for integers; assumption-literal cores with deletion-based MUS","budgets":{"maxConflicts":300000,"maxPropagations":60000000,"maxPivots":2000000,"maxSplits":5000,"maxSolves":2000,"maxWork":40000000,"maxMillis":25000},"stats":{"conflicts":2,"decisions":5,"propagations":115,"restarts":0,"learnedClauses":1,"theoryConflicts":0,"pivots":0,"splits":0,"musSolves":3,"satVariables":25},"inputHash":"0x657fbb42a39c55d7f3a721772473f8d3a921c9febce475136b4c6fd16ef2950e","irHash":"0xb459abe72b58df2daf72e44d949f50969c29c9908aca3ff3991193c10a80becb"}},"_provenance":{"version":"writerslogic-provenance/1","issuer":"did:web:agents.writerslogic.com","verify":{"endpoint":"POST /api/v1/verify-provenance","did":"did:web:agents.writerslogic.com"},"manifest":{"format":"application/json","instance_id":"xmp:iid:416a98ba-9482-40ad-b391-d3c37ae8b628","claim_generator_info":[{"name":"WritersLogic x402 Agent Hub","version":"2.0.0"}],"title":"SMT Contract & Policy Logic Prover","assertions":[{"label":"c2pa.actions.v2","data":{"actions":[{"action":"c2pa.created","when":"2026-11-06T17:56:44.553Z","softwareAgent":{"name":"writerslogic-agent-hub/smt-contract-prover","version":"2.0.0"},"digitalSourceType":"http://cv.iptc.org/newscodes/digitalsourcetype/trainedAlgorithmicMedia","parameters":{"endpoint":"POST /api/v1/prove-contract-logic","inputDigest":{"alg":"sha256","hash":"657fbb42a39c55d7f3a721772473f8d3a921c9febce475136b4c6fd16ef2950e","canonicalization":"JCS"}}}]}},{"label":"c2pa.hash.data","data":{"alg":"sha256","hash":"981f1457e2580b85baad554723cae2ab0e88b7657eac7d6538dfd2e3def9e969","name":"jcs-canonical-json(data)"}}]},"credential":{"@context":["https://www.w3.org/ns/credentials/v2"],"id":"urn:uuid:af097b68-2b6a-4531-941e-8e97a808a4ca","type":["VerifiableCredential","AgentOutputCredential"],"issuer":"did:web:agents.writerslogic.com","validFrom":"2026-11-06T17:56:44.553Z","credentialSubject":{"id":"urn:sha256:981f1457e2580b85baad554723cae2ab0e88b7657eac7d6538dfd2e3def9e969","agent":"smt-contract-prover","endpoint":"POST /api/v1/prove-contract-logic","outputDigest":{"alg":"sha256","value":"981f1457e2580b85baad554723cae2ab0e88b7657eac7d6538dfd2e3def9e969","canonicalization":"JCS"},"inputDigest":{"alg":"sha256","value":"657fbb42a39c55d7f3a721772473f8d3a921c9febce475136b4c6fd16ef2950e","canonicalization":"JCS"},"manifestDigest":{"alg":"sha256","value":"7204f5dcd0d0921b3f76a24c3c45e9184f728ec46f3005c3e3494652706110e9","canonicalization":"JCS"},"ingredients":[],"payment":{"scheme":"api-key","network":"eip155:8453","payer":"sample"}},"proof":{"type":"DataIntegrityProof","cryptosuite":"eddsa-jcs-2022","created":"2026-11-06T17:56:44.553Z","verificationMethod":"did:web:agents.writerslogic.com#key-1","proofPurpose":"assertionMethod","proofValue":"z3eq59ni2Vd1vieFg4rR3YfC5HD49kC97Kyo5Nh7xktC85DN6PxyeELZpe1it82EAeGBtwxaS268vxL9kL7xTx7Go"}},"ethSignature":{"type":"EIP-191","signer":"did:pkh:eip155:8453:0x3DBd42560cA7a7E448A2c7DfC9E785526189411f","address":"0x3DBd42560cA7a7E448A2c7DfC9E785526189411f","message":"writerslogic-provenance:efe0baf7da4b857435fd97532ea744595964fc17117392782c8676c4be29186f","signature":"0xd9ada233684f451f603e5caf1cb259e1692b1d88cde2fd4b8f97539acf9cc36748408979331bfcf4e86eb89ebdf30a8ba03e8774b762ca0b921061b752bdd6721c"}}}